Guide to the canto Where we are Dante is still in the Heaven of Venus. The blessed souls dance in a circle, and one of them comes forward to speak to him. The pause is brief, but the encounter soon slides from personal recollection into a reasoning on how divine providence guides the heavens and their influences on men.
Whom we meet Charlemagne is the soul who presents himself to Dante. He recalls the three crowns he should have worn: Provence, southern Italy, and Sicily, lamenting the evil governance that tore them from him. After the political accusations against his brother, the voice changes tone and explains to Dante why men are born so different from one another.
What to expect Charlemagne makes clear that providence moves the heavens, but it is nature that shapes each person’s character, and the fault lies with men, who assign social roles contrary to natural disposition. The lesson leaves open the knot between celestial destiny and human responsibility, a question that will return in the following cantos.
The world used in its peril to believe
1 That the fair Cypria delirious love
2 Rayed out, in the third epicycle turning;
3 In former times the world, to its own peril, believed that lovely Venus, turning in the third epicycle, radiated reckless love. · Verses 1-3
Wherefore not only unto her paid honour
4 Of sacrifices and of votive cry
5 The ancient nations in the ancient error,
6 But both Dione honoured they and Cupid,
7 That as her mother, this one as her son,
8 And said that he had sat in Dido's lap;
9 And they from her, whence I beginning take,
10 Took the denomination of the star
11 That woos the sun, now following, now in front.
12 And from her, from whom I take my beginning, came the name given to the star that the sun now courts, now from the cup, now from the brow. · Verses 10-12
I was not ware of our ascending to it;
13 But of our being in it gave full faith
14 My Lady whom I saw more beauteous grow.
15 And as within a flame a spark is seen,
16 And as within a voice a voice discerned,
17 When one is steadfast, and one comes and goes,
18 Within that light beheld I other lamps
19 Move in a circle, speeding more and less,
20 Methinks in measure of their inward vision.
21 So I saw within that light other lamps moving in a circle, some faster, some slower, according, I believe, to the depth of their inner vision. · Verses 19-21
From a cold cloud descended never winds,
22 Or visible or not, so rapidly
23 They would not laggard and impeded seem
24 To any one who had those lights divine
25 Seen come towards us, leaving the gyration
26 Begun at first in the high Seraphim.
27 And behind those that most in front appeared
28 Sounded "Osanna!" so that never since
29 To hear again was I without desire.
30 Then unto us more nearly one approached,
31 And it alone began: "We all are ready
32 Unto thy pleasure, that thou joy in us.
33 We turn around with the celestial Princes,
34 One gyre and one gyration and one thirst,
35 To whom thou in the world of old didst say,
36 'Ye who, intelligent, the third heaven are moving;'
37 And are so full of love, to pleasure thee
38 A little quiet will not be less sweet."
39 "We revolve together with the celestial princes with one circle, one motion, and one longing, you to whom already in the world you addressed the line: 'You who, with understanding, move the third heaven'; and we are so full of love that, to please you, a little stillness will be no less sweet." · Verses 34-39
After these eyes of mine themselves had offered
40 Unto my Lady reverently, and she
41 Content and certain of herself had made them,
42 Back to the light they turned, which so great promise
43 Made of itself, and "Say, who art thou?" was
44 My voice, imprinted with a great affection.
45 They turned to the light that had promised so much, and my voice, marked by deep feeling, said: "Ah, who are you?" · Verses 43-45
O how and how much I beheld it grow
46 With the new joy that superadded was
47 Unto its joys, as soon as I had spoken!
48 And how much and how greatly I saw her grow in joy, from the new gladness that, when I spoke, was added to her rejoicing! · Verses 46-48
Thus changed, it said to me: "The world possessed me
49 Short time below; and, if it had been more,
50 Much evil will be which would not have been.
51 Radiant as she was, she said to me: "The world held me only a little while; and had I stayed longer, much evil would befall, which instead will not." · Verses 49-51
My gladness keepeth me concealed from thee,
52 Which rayeth round about me, and doth hide me
53 Like as a creature swathed in its own silk.
54 Much didst thou love me, and thou hadst good reason;
55 For had I been below, I should have shown thee
56 Somewhat beyond the foliage of my love.
57 That left-hand margin, which doth bathe itself
58 In Rhone, when it is mingled with the Sorgue,
59 Me for its lord awaited in due time,
60 And that horn of Ausonia, which is towned
61 With Bari, with Gaeta and Catona,
62 Whence Tronto and Verde in the sea disgorge.
63 "And that horn of Ausonia that encloses Bari, Gaeta, and Catona, where the Tronto and the Verde pour into the sea." · Verses 61-63
Already flashed upon my brow the crown
64 Of that dominion which the Danube waters
65 After the German borders it abandons;
66 And beautiful Trinacria, that is murky
67 'Twixt Pachino and Peloro, (on the gulf
68 Which greatest scath from Eurus doth receive,)
69 Not through Typhoeus, but through nascent sulphur,
70 Would have awaited her own monarchs still,
71 Through me from Charles descended and from Rudolph,
72 "Not for Typhoeus, but for the sulfur that rises there, would still be awaiting its kings, born of me and of Charles and of Rudolf." · Verses 70-72
If evil lordship, that exasperates ever
73 The subject populations, had not moved
74 Palermo to the outcry of 'Death! death!'
75 "Had not evil lordship, which always afflicts the subject peoples, stirred Palermo to cry out: 'Death, death!'" · Verses 73-75
And if my brother could but this foresee,
76 The greedy poverty of Catalonia
77 Straight would he flee, that it might not molest him;
78 For verily 'tis needful to provide,
79 Through him or other, so that on his bark
80 Already freighted no more freight be placed.
81 His nature, which from liberal covetous
82 Descended, such a soldiery would need
83 As should not care for hoarding in a chest."
84 "Because I do believe the lofty joy
85 Thy speech infuses into me, my Lord,
86 Where every good thing doth begin and end
87 Thou seest as I see it, the more grateful
88 Is it to me; and this too hold I dear,
89 That gazing upon God thou dost discern it.
90 Then I said to him: "Because I believe that the high joy your words pour into me, my lord, there where every good has its ending and its beginning, is seen by you as I see it, it is the more welcome to me; and this too I hold dear, because you discern it by gazing upon God." · Verses 85-90
Glad hast thou made me; so make clear to me,
91 Since speaking thou hast stirred me up to doubt,
92 How from sweet seed can bitter issue forth."
93 "You have made me glad, and now make this clear to me: since, in speaking, you have stirred my doubt as to how something bitter can spring from a sweet seed." · Verses 91-93
This I to him; and he to me: "If I
94 Can show to thee a truth, to what thou askest
95 Thy face thou'lt hold as thou dost hold thy back.
96 The Good which all the realm thou art ascending
97 Turns and contents, maketh its providence
98 To be a power within these bodies vast;
99 And not alone the natures are foreseen
100 Within the mind that in itself is perfect,
101 But they together with their preservation.
102 For whatsoever thing this bow shoots forth
103 Falls foreordained unto an end foreseen,
104 Even as a shaft directed to its mark.
105 If that were not, the heaven which thou dost walk
106 Would in such manner its effects produce,
107 That they no longer would be arts, but ruins.
108 This cannot be, if the Intelligences
109 That keep these stars in motion are not maimed,
110 And maimed the First that has not made them perfect.
111 "And this cannot be, unless the intelligences that move these stars are defective, and defective the first, which has not made them perfect." · Verses 109-111
Wilt thou this truth have clearer made to thee?"
112 And I: "Not so; for 'tis impossible
113 That nature tire, I see, in what is needful."
114 Whence he again: "Now say, would it be worse
115 For men on earth were they not citizens?"
116 "Yes," I replied; "and here I ask no reason."
117 Then he resumed: "Tell me: would it be worse for man on earth, if he did not live in fellowship?" "Yes," I answered, "and on this I ask no further reason." · Verses 115-117
"And can they be so, if below they live not
118 Diversely unto offices diverse?
119 No, if your master writeth well for you."
120 So came he with deductions to this point;
121 Then he concluded: "Therefore it behoves
122 The roots of your effects to be diverse.
123 Hence one is Solon born, another Xerxes,
124 Another Melchisedec, and another he
125 Who, flying through the air, his son did lose.
126 "Hence one is born a Solon and another a Xerxes, another a Melchizedek and another he who, flying through the air, lost his son." · Verses 124-126
Revolving Nature, which a signet is
127 To mortal wax, doth practise well her art,
128 But not one inn distinguish from another;
129 "The circular nature, which stamps its seal upon mortal wax, does its work well, but it does not distinguish one lodging from another." · Verses 127-129
Thence happens it that Esau differeth
130 In seed from Jacob; and Quirinus comes
131 From sire so vile that he is given to Mars.
132 A generated nature its own way
133 Would always make like its progenitors,
134 If Providence divine were not triumphant.
135 Now that which was behind thee is before thee;
136 But that thou know that I with thee am pleased,
137 With a corollary will I mantle thee.
138 Evermore nature, if it fortune find
139 Discordant to it, like each other seed
140 Out of its region, maketh evil thrift;
141 "Nature, if she meets a fortune at odds with her, like any seed outside its own region, always comes to a bad outcome." · Verses 139-141
And if the world below would fix its mind
142 On the foundation which is laid by nature,
143 Pursuing that, 'twould have the people good.
144 But you unto religion wrench aside
145 Him who was born to gird him with the sword,
146 And make a king of him who is for sermons;
147 Therefore your footsteps wander from the road."
148 The list of places is under editorial review.
https://divinacommediaonline.it/en/paradise/canto-8