Charlemagne and the diversity of human natures
Guide to the canto
Dante is still in the Heaven of Venus. The blessed souls dance in a circle, and one of them comes forward to speak to him. The pause is brief, but the encounter soon slides from personal recollection into a reasoning on how divine providence guides the heavens and their influences on men.
Whom we meet
Charlemagne is the soul who presents himself to Dante. He recalls the three crowns he should have worn: Provence, southern Italy, and Sicily, lamenting the evil governance that tore them from him. After the political accusations against his brother, the voice changes tone and explains to Dante why men are born so different from one another.
What to expect
Charlemagne makes clear that providence moves the heavens, but it is nature that shapes each person’s character, and the fault lies with men, who assign social roles contrary to natural disposition. The lesson leaves open the knot between celestial destiny and human responsibility, a question that will return in the following cantos.
Read the canto
Paraphrase