Guide to the canto Where we are Dante is still in the Heaven of the Sun, halted before the two crowns of wise lights that have resumed their circular arrangement. Saint Thomas, who spoke in the previous canto, takes the floor again and reads in the pilgrim's thoughts the doubt left by two of his expressions. The canto opens with an invective against the foolishness of mortals, who pursue vain goods while heaven welcomes those who have freed themselves from them.
Whom we meet Saint Francis remains absent but is the true protagonist: Thomas retraces his birth in Assisi, his youth, his choice of Poverty as his bride, his renunciation of his father, the first approval of the rule obtained from Innocent III, the second crown given by Honorius III, the preaching to the Sultan, the stigmata received on the mountain between the Tiber and the Arno, his death, and the entrusting of Poverty to the friars. The first companions enter the scene—Bernard, Giles, and Sylvester—who strip off their shoes to follow Francis.
What to expect After this portrait of Francis, Dante will hear from Saint Bonaventure the specular account of Saint Dominic, the other prince chosen by Providence to guide the Church. The reader should expect a change of voice, because another light of the crown will speak, and the closing on the defects of the Franciscan order foreshadows a comparison between the two guides and the risks of internal decay within the mendicant orders.
O Thou insensate care of mortal men,
1 How inconclusive are the syllogisms
2 That make thee beat thy wings in downward flight!
3 One after laws and one to aphorisms
4 Was going, and one following the priesthood,
5 And one to reign by force or sophistry,
6 Some devoted themselves to the law, some to medicine, some to the priesthood, and some to seizing power by force or by sophistry. · Verses 4-6
And one in theft, and one in state affairs,
7 One in the pleasures of the flesh involved
8 Wearied himself, one gave himself to ease;
9 Some toiled to rob, some for public business, some wrapped themselves in the pleasures of the flesh, and some gave themselves over to idleness. · Verses 7-9
When I, from all these things emancipate,
10 With Beatrice above there in the Heavens
11 With such exceeding glory was received!
12 When, freed from all these occupations, I found myself with Beatrice in heaven, welcomed with so great glory. · Verses 10-12
When each one had returned unto that point
13 Within the circle where it was before,
14 It stood as in a candlestick a candle;
15 And from within the effulgence which at first
16 Had spoken unto me, I heard begin
17 Smiling while it more luminous became:
18 And I heard, within that light that had spoken to me first, beginning to speak with a smile, growing still more radiant. · Verses 16-18
"Even as I am kindled in its ray,
19 So, looking into the Eternal Light,
20 The occasion of thy thoughts I apprehend.
21 Thou doubtest, and wouldst have me to resift
22 In language so extended and so open
23 My speech, that to thy sense it may be plain,
24 "Just as I shine with His ray, so, gazing into the eternal light, I learn the source of your thoughts. You have doubts, and you wish my words to be set out in a language so open and so spacious that they meet your understanding." · Verses 19-24
Where just before I said, 'where well one fattens,'
25 And where I said, 'there never rose a second;'
26 And here 'tis needful we distinguish well.
27 The Providence, which governeth the world
28 With counsel, wherein all created vision
29 Is vanquished ere it reach unto the bottom,
30 (So that towards her own Beloved might go
31 The bride of Him who, uttering a loud cry,
32 Espoused her with his consecrated blood,
33 Self-confident and unto Him more faithful,)
34 Two Princes did ordain in her behoof,
35 Which on this side and that might be her guide.
36 "So that the bride of Him who, with loud cries, espoused her to Himself with His blessed blood might go toward her beloved, secure in herself and even more faithful to Him, He appointed two princes in her favor, to be her guide on this side and on that." · Verses 31-36
The one was all seraphical in ardour;
37 The other by his wisdom upon earth
38 A splendour was of light cherubical.
39 One will I speak of, for of both is spoken
40 In praising one, whichever may be taken,
41 Because unto one end their labours were.
42 "The one was all seraphic fire; the other, for his wisdom, was on earth a splendor of cherubic light. I will speak of one alone, because in praising one one speaks of both, whichever you take, since their works were directed to a single end." · Verses 37-42
Between Tupino and the stream that falls
43 Down from the hill elect of blessed Ubald,
44 A fertile slope of lofty mountain hangs,
45 From which Perugia feels the cold and heat
46 Through Porta Sole, and behind it weep
47 Gualdo and Nocera their grievous yoke.
48 "Between the Tupino and the stream that descends from the hill chosen by blessed Ubaldo, there slopes a fertile side of a high mountain, from which Perugia feels both cold and heat at Porta Sole; and behind it Nocera and Gualdo weep beneath a heavy yoke." · Verses 43-48
From out that slope, there where it breaketh most
49 Its steepness, rose upon the world a sun
50 As this one does sometimes from out the Ganges;
51 Therefore let him who speaketh of that place,
52 Say not Ascesi, for he would say little,
53 But Orient, if he properly would speak.
54 "From this slope, where it breaks its steepness most, a sun was born into the world, as sometimes the sun is born from the Ganges. Therefore let whoever speaks of this place not say Assisi, for that would be saying too little, but the East, if he wishes to speak truly." · Verses 49-54
He was not yet far distant from his rising
55 Before he had begun to make the earth
56 Some comfort from his mighty virtue feel.
57 For he in youth his father's wrath incurred
58 For certain Dame, to whom, as unto death,
59 The gate of pleasure no one doth unlock;
60 "He had not wandered far from there when he began to make the earth feel some comfort of his great virtue; for, for the sake of that lady, as a young man he went to war with his father—to whom no one opens the gate of pleasure, as one does to death." · Verses 55-60
And was before his spiritual court
61 'Et coram patre' unto her united;
62 Then day by day more fervently he loved her.
63 She, reft of her first husband, scorned, obscure,
64 One thousand and one hundred years and more,
65 Waited without a suitor till he came.
66 "Before his spiritual court and in the presence of his father he was joined to her; and then, day by day, he loved her more. This lady, deprived of her first husband, had remained for more than eleven hundred years despised and obscure, without any suitor, until he came." · Verses 61-66
Naught it availed to hear, that with Amyclas
67 Found her unmoved at sounding of his voice
68 He who struck terror into all the world;
69 Naught it availed being constant and undaunted,
70 So that, when Mary still remained below,
71 She mounted up with Christ upon the cross.
72 "It did not help her that the man who struck terror into the whole world found her faithful with Amyclas, at the sound of his voice; it did not help her to be steadfast and brave, so that, where Mary remained below, she wept with Christ upon the cross." · Verses 67-72
But that too darkly I may not proceed,
73 Francis and Poverty for these two lovers
74 Take thou henceforward in my speech diffuse.
75 Their concord and their joyous semblances,
76 The love, the wonder, and the sweet regard,
77 They made to be the cause of holy thoughts;
78 "But so that I may not proceed too obscurely, take Francis and Poverty from now on, in my broad speech, as these two lovers. Their harmony and their joyful faces, their love, their wonder, and their gentle gaze gave rise to holy thoughts." · Verses 73-78
So much so that the venerable Bernard
79 First bared his feet, and after so great peace
80 Ran, and, in running, thought himself too slow.
81 O wealth unknown! O veritable good!
82 Giles bares his feet, and bares his feet Sylvester
83 Behind the bridegroom, so doth please the bride!
84 "So much so that the venerable Bernard was the first to take off his shoes, and ran after so great a peace and, running, thought himself slow. O unknown riches! O fertile good! Giles takes off his shoes, Sylvester takes off his shoes, following the bridegroom, so pleasing is the bride." · Verses 79-84
Then goes his way that father and that master,
85 He and his Lady and that family
86 Which now was girding on the humble cord;
87 Nor cowardice of heart weighed down his brow
88 At being son of Peter Bernardone,
89 Nor for appearing marvellously scorned;
90 But regally his hard determination
91 To Innocent he opened, and from him
92 Received the primal seal upon his Order.
93 After the people mendicant increased
94 Behind this man, whose admirable life
95 Better in glory of the heavens were sung,
96 Incoronated with a second crown
97 Was through Honorius by the Eternal Spirit
98 The holy purpose of this Archimandrite.
99 And when he had, through thirst of martyrdom,
100 In the proud presence of the Sultan preached
101 Christ and the others who came after him,
102 "The holy desire of this leader was crowned with a second crown by Honorius, by the will of the eternal Spirit. And then, thirsting for martyrdom, he preached Christ and the others who followed him before the proud Sultan." · Verses 97-102
And, finding for conversion too unripe
103 The folk, and not to tarry there in vain,
104 Returned to fruit of the Italic grass,
105 On the rude rock 'twixt Tiber and the Arno
106 From Christ did he receive the final seal,
107 Which during two whole years his members bore.
108 "And finding the people too stubborn to convert, and not wishing to stay there in vain, he returned to the harvest of the Italian soil, and on the rough rock between the Tiber and the Arno he received from Christ the last seal, which his limbs bore for two years." · Verses 103-108
When He, who chose him unto so much good,
109 Was pleased to draw him up to the reward
110 That he had merited by being lowly,
111 Unto his friars, as to the rightful heirs,
112 His most dear Lady did he recommend,
113 And bade that they should love her faithfully;
114 "When it pleased Him who had appointed him for so great a good to draw him up to the reward he had merited by making himself small, he commended to his friars, as to rightful heirs, his dearest lady, and commanded them to love her faithfully." · Verses 109-114
And from her bosom the illustrious soul
115 Wished to depart, returning to its realm,
116 And for its body wished no other bier.
117 Think now what man was he, who was a fit
118 Companion over the high seas to keep
119 The bark of Peter to its proper bearings.
120 "And the illustrious soul willed to depart from her bosom, returning to his kingdom, and for his body would have no other bier. Think now what manner of man was the worthy colleague chosen to keep the bark of Peter on course upon the high sea." · Verses 115-120
And this man was our Patriarch; hence whoever
121 Doth follow him as he commands can see
122 That he is laden with good merchandise.
123 But for new pasturage his flock has grown
124 So greedy, that it is impossible
125 They be not scattered over fields diverse;
126 "And this was our patriarch; therefore you can judge that whoever follows him, as he commands, carries a good cargo home. But his flock has grown greedy for new fodder, so that it cannot help scattering over different pastures." · Verses 121-126
And in proportion as his sheep remote
127 And vagabond go farther off from him,
128 More void of milk return they to the fold.
129 Verily some there are that fear a hurt,
130 And keep close to the shepherd; but so few,
131 That little cloth doth furnish forth their hoods.
132 "And the more his sheep stray from him, wandering far off, the more they come back to the fold empty of milk. There are indeed some that fear the harm and press close to the shepherd; but they are so few that their cloaks furnish little cloth." · Verses 127-132
Now if my utterance be not indistinct,
133 If thine own hearing hath attentive been,
134 If thou recall to mind what I have said,
135 In part contented shall thy wishes be;
136 For thou shalt see the plant that's chipped away,
137 And the rebuke that lieth in the words,
138 'Where well one fattens, if he strayeth not.'"
139 "Now, if my words have not been empty, if your hearing has been attentive, if you recall to mind what has been said, your desire will be in part satisfied, for you will see the plant from which the splinter is cut, and you will see the rebuke that proves: 'Where one grows fat, if one does not go astray.'" · Verses 133-139
The list of places is under editorial review.
https://divinacommediaonline.it/en/paradise/canto-11