← Canto XIX

Purgatory, Canto XX

Canto XXI →

Hugh Capet and the trembling of the mountain

Guide to the canto

Where we are

We proceed along the fifth circle, where the avaricious lie prone on the ground and recite examples of poverty and of punished wealth. Dante draws near to learn who is speaking, and the dialogue opens upon the recollection of the she-wolf, image of greed, with the expectation of a liberator who will drive her away. The scene will remain still until an unexpected trembling of the mountain, heralding a change.

Whom we meet

Hugh Capet, progenitor of the Capetians, recounts his own rise and the sins of his descendants, among them the king who humiliates Charles of Anjou and the prophecy of a future Charles unarmed, destined to strike Florence. With him also speak and recall the other souls of the circle, who at night overturn into opposite examples the praises of the day: Pygmalion, Midas, Achan, Sapphira, Heliodorus, Polymestor, and Crassus.

What to expect

The reader now expects a turning point: the trembling of the mountain and the song Gloria in excelsis mark the passage to the sixth circle, that of the gluttonous. The question remains suspended as to the meaning of that upheaval and of the new moral examples that will accompany Dante among the souls stretched out on the ground.

Read the canto

Purgatory · Canto XX
Translated by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (1867).
Paraphrase

Ill strives the will against a better will;

1

Therefore, to pleasure him, against my pleasure

2

I drew the sponge not saturate from the water.

3

Onward I moved, and onward moved my Leader,

4

Through vacant places, skirting still the rock,

5

As on a wall close to the battlements;

6

For they that through their eyes pour drop by drop

7

The malady which all the world pervades,

8

On the other side too near the verge approach.

9

Accursed mayst thou be, thou old she-wolf,

10

That more than all the other beasts hast prey,

11

Because of hunger infinitely hollow!

12

O heaven, in whose gyrations some appear

13

To think conditions here below are changed,

14

When will he come through whom she shall depart?

15

Onward we went with footsteps slow and scarce,

16

And I attentive to the shades I heard

17

Piteously weeping and bemoaning them;

18

And I by peradventure heard "Sweet Mary!"

19

Uttered in front of us amid the weeping

20

Even as a woman does who is in child-birth;

21

And in continuance: "How poor thou wast

22

Is manifested by that hostelry

23

Where thou didst lay thy sacred burden down."

24

Thereafterward I heard: "O good Fabricius,

25

Virtue with poverty didst thou prefer

26

To the possession of great wealth with vice."

27

So pleasurable were these words to me

28

That I drew farther onward to have knowledge

29

Touching that spirit whence they seemed to come.

30

He furthermore was speaking of the largess

31

Which Nicholas unto the maidens gave,

32

In order to conduct their youth to honour.

33

"O soul that dost so excellently speak,

34

Tell me who wast thou," said I, "and why only

35

Thou dost renew these praises well deserved?

36

Not without recompense shall be thy word,

37

If I return to finish the short journey

38

Of that life which is flying to its end."

39

And he: "I'll tell thee, not for any comfort

40

I may expect from earth, but that so much

41

Grace shines in thee or ever thou art dead.

42

I was the root of that malignant plant

43

Which overshadows all the Christian world,

44

So that good fruit is seldom gathered from it;

45

But if Douay and Ghent, and Lille and Bruges

46

Had Power, soon vengeance would be taken on it;

47

And this I pray of Him who judges all.

48

Hugh Capet was I called upon the earth;

49

From me were born the Louises and Philips,

50

By whom in later days has France been governed.

51

I was the son of a Parisian butcher,

52

What time the ancient kings had perished all,

53

Excepting one, contrite in cloth of gray.

54

I found me grasping in my hands the rein

55

Of the realm's government, and so great power

56

Of new acquest, and so with friends abounding,

57

That to the widowed diadem promoted

58

The head of mine own offspring was, from whom

59

The consecrated bones of these began.

60

So long as the great dowry of Provence

61

Out of my blood took not the sense of shame,

62

'Twas little worth, but still it did no harm.

63

Then it began with falsehood and with force

64

Its rapine; and thereafter, for amends,

65

Took Ponthieu, Normandy, and Gascony.

66

Charles came to Italy, and for amends

67

A victim made of Conradin, and then

68

Thrust Thomas back to heaven, for amends.

69

A time I see, not very distant now,

70

Which draweth forth another Charles from France,

71

The better to make known both him and his.

72

Unarmed he goes, and only with the lance

73

That Judas jousted with; and that he thrusts

74

So that he makes the paunch of Florence burst.

75

He thence not land, but sin and infamy,

76

Shall gain, so much more grievous to himself

77

As the more light such damage he accounts.

78

The other, now gone forth, ta'en in his ship,

79

See I his daughter sell, and chaffer for her

80

As corsairs do with other female slaves.

81

What more, O Avarice, canst thou do to us,

82

Since thou my blood so to thyself hast drawn,

83

It careth not for its own proper flesh?

84

That less may seem the future ill and past,

85

I see the flower-de-luce Alagna enter,

86

And Christ in his own Vicar captive made.

87

I see him yet another time derided;

88

I see renewed the vinegar and gall,

89

And between living thieves I see him slain.

90

I see the modern Pilate so relentless,

91

This does not sate him, but without decretal

92

He to the temple bears his sordid sails!

93

When, O my Lord! shall I be joyful made

94

By looking on the vengeance which, concealed,

95

Makes sweet thine anger in thy secrecy?

96

What I was saying of that only bride

97

Of the Holy Ghost, and which occasioned thee

98

To turn towards me for some commentary,

99

So long has been ordained to all our prayers

100

As the day lasts; but when the night comes on,

101

Contrary sound we take instead thereof.

102

At that time we repeat Pygmalion,

103

Of whom a traitor, thief, and parricide

104

Made his insatiable desire of gold;

105

And the misery of avaricious Midas,

106

That followed his inordinate demand,

107

At which forevermore one needs but laugh.

108

The foolish Achan each one then records,

109

And how he stole the spoils; so that the wrath

110

Of Joshua still appears to sting him here.

111

Then we accuse Sapphira with her husband,

112

We laud the hoof-beats Heliodorus had,

113

And the whole mount in infamy encircles

114

Polymnestor who murdered Polydorus.

115

Here finally is cried: 'O Crassus, tell us,

116

For thou dost know, what is the taste of gold?'

117

Sometimes we speak, one loud, another low,

118

According to desire of speech, that spurs us

119

To greater now and now to lesser pace.

120

But in the good that here by day is talked of,

121

Erewhile alone I was not; yet near by

122

No other person lifted up his voice."

123

From him already we departed were,

124

And made endeavour to o'ercome the road

125

As much as was permitted to our power,

126

When I perceived, like something that is falling,

127

The mountain tremble, whence a chill seized on me,

128

As seizes him who to his death is going.

129

Certes so violently shook not Delos,

130

Before Latona made her nest therein

131

To give birth to the two eyes of the heaven.

132

Then upon all sides there began a cry,

133

Such that the Master drew himself towards me,

134

Saying, "Fear not, while I am guiding thee."

135

"Gloria in excelsis Deo," all

136

Were saying, from what near I comprehended,

137

Where it was possible to hear the cry.

138

We paused immovable and in suspense,

139

Even as the shepherds who first heard that song,

140

Until the trembling ceased, and it was finished.

141

Then we resumed again our holy path,

142

Watching the shades that lay upon the ground,

143

Already turned to their accustomed plaint.

144

No ignorance ever with so great a strife

145

Had rendered me importunate to know,

146

If erreth not in this my memory,

147

As meditating then I seemed to have;

148

Nor out of haste to question did I dare,

149

Nor of myself I there could aught perceive;

150

So I went onward timorous and thoughtful.

151