Guide to the canto Where we are Dante emerges from the smoke of the third cornice, where sight returns slowly as when fog thins out in the mountains. The two pilgrims climb the staircase up to the fourth circle, where they stop, and the stars begin to appear as night approaches. Here the journey halts: it is the point at which Virgil can finally speak in an open place, far from the smoke.
Whom we meet Only the angel of the fourth circle comes on the scene, who with a beat of wings erases a P from Dante's forehead and announces the beatitude of the peacemakers. Virgil takes on the role of master for the first time in this canto: he explains the structure of love, the true driver of the punishments that await them. Marco Lombardo, encountered in the previous canto, does not reappear.
What to expect From here on love is the guiding thread: Dante will learn to distinguish right love from that which runs toward the good with a corrupted measure, through excess or defect. In the coming cantos he will meet the penitents who loved too much or too little, and a new face of moral error will take shape, no longer anger but desire out of season.
Remember, Reader, if e'er in the Alps
1 A mist o'ertook thee, through which thou couldst see
2 Not otherwise than through its membrane mole,
3 Reader, if you have ever been caught in the mountains in a fog so thick that you could see no more than a mole beneath its fur, remember that well, because now you will get a clear idea of how my sight was when I came out of that dense vapor. · Verses 1-3
How, when the vapours humid and condensed
4 Begin to dissipate themselves, the sphere
5 Of the sun feebly enters in among them,
6 For, just as it happens when the damp, packed vapors begin to thin out and the disk of the sun filters weakly through them, so faint was the light that came back to strike my eyes. · Verses 4-6
And thy imagination will be swift
7 In coming to perceive how I re-saw
8 The sun at first, that was already setting.
9 Thus, to the faithful footsteps of my Master
10 Mating mine own, I issued from that cloud
11 To rays already dead on the low shores.
12 Then, keeping pace with the sure steps of my guide, I came out of that thick cloud and found myself, on the low shore, beneath the day's last rays, already dying. · Verses 10-12
O thou, Imagination, that dost steal us
13 So from without sometimes, that man perceives not,
14 Although around may sound a thousand trumpets,
15 O imagination, that sometimes snatches us away from the outside world with such force that not even a thousand trumpets sounding around us could call us back, who sets you in motion, if the senses offer you nothing? · Verses 13-15
Who moveth thee, if sense impel thee not?
16 Moves thee a light, which in the heaven takes form,
17 By self, or by a will that downward guides it.
18 Of her impiety, who changed her form
19 Into the bird that most delights in singing,
20 In my imagining appeared the trace;
21 And hereupon my mind was so withdrawn
22 Within itself, that from without there came
23 Nothing that then might be received by it.
24 Then reigned within my lofty fantasy
25 One crucified, disdainful and ferocious
26 In countenance, and even thus was dying.
27 Then, inside my high imagination, there rained down the vision of a crucified figure, fierce and pitiless in his gaze, and in that scene he was dying. · Verses 25-27
Around him were the great Ahasuerus,
28 Esther his wife, and the just Mordecai,
29 Who was in word and action so entire.
30 Around him stood the great Ahasuerus, his wife Esther, and the righteous Mordecai, who was equally irreproachable in word and deed. · Verses 28-30
And even as this image burst asunder
31 Of its own self, in fashion of a bubble
32 In which the water it was made of fails,
33 There rose up in my vision a young maiden
34 Bitterly weeping, and she said: "O queen,
35 Why hast thou wished in anger to be naught?
36 Thou'st slain thyself, Lavinia not to lose;
37 Now hast thou lost me; I am she who mourns,
38 Mother, at thine ere at another's ruin."
39 A maiden appeared to me, weeping desperately, and saying: "O queen, why in your rage did you choose to destroy yourself? You killed yourself rather than lose Lavinia, and now you have destroyed me as well! I am the one who mourns your death before that of anyone else." · Verses 34-39
As sleep is broken, when upon a sudden
40 New light strikes in upon the eyelids closed,
41 And broken quivers ere it dieth wholly,
42 So this imagining of mine fell down
43 As soon as the effulgence smote my face,
44 Greater by far than what is in our wont.
45 So my vision collapsed at once, as soon as a light, far more intense than what we are used to, struck my face. · Verses 43-45
I turned me round to see where I might be,
46 When said a voice, "Here is the passage up;"
47 Which from all other purposes removed me,
48 I was already looking about to understand where I was, when a voice said, "Here is where we go up," drawing me away from any other thought. · Verses 46-48
And made my wish so full of eagerness
49 To look and see who was it that was speaking,
50 It never rests till meeting face to face;
51 But as before the sun, which quells the sight,
52 And in its own excess its figure veils,
53 Even so my power was insufficient here.
54 "This is a spirit divine, who in the way
55 Of going up directs us without asking,
56 And who with his own light himself conceals.
57 He does with us as man doth with himself;
58 For he who sees the need, and waits the asking,
59 Malignly leans already tow'rds denial.
60 Accord we now our feet to such inviting,
61 Let us make haste to mount ere it grow dark;
62 For then we could not till the day return."
63 Thus my Conductor said; and I and he
64 Together turned our footsteps to a stairway;
65 And I, as soon as the first step I reached,
66 Near me perceived a motion as of wings,
67 And fanning in the face, and saying, "'Beati
68 Pacifici,' who are without ill anger."
69 I felt almost a stirring of wings close to me, a breath of air on my face, and a voice that said: "Blessed are the peaceful, who are without evil anger!" · Verses 67-69
Already over us were so uplifted
70 The latest sunbeams, which the night pursues,
71 That upon many sides the stars appeared.
72 The last rays of day, those that go before the night, had already risen well above us, and the stars were beginning to appear in several parts of the sky. · Verses 70-72
"O manhood mine, why dost thou vanish so?"
73 I said within myself; for I perceived
74 The vigour of my legs was put in truce.
75 We at the point were where no more ascends
76 The stairway upward, and were motionless,
77 Even as a ship, which at the shore arrives;
78 And I gave heed a little, if I might hear
79 Aught whatsoever in the circle new;
80 Then to my Master turned me round and said:
81 "Say, my sweet Father, what delinquency
82 Is purged here in the circle where we are?
83 Although our feet may pause, pause not thy speech."
84 And he to me: "The love of good, remiss
85 In what it should have done, is here restored;
86 Here plied again the ill-belated oar;
87 But still more openly to understand,
88 Turn unto me thy mind, and thou shalt gather
89 Some profitable fruit from our delay.
90 Neither Creator nor a creature ever,
91 Son," he began, "was destitute of love
92 Natural or spiritual; and thou knowest it.
93 He began by saying: "My son, there has never been, neither in the Creator nor in any creature, a being without love, whether natural or of the soul; and you know this well." · Verses 91-93
The natural was ever without error;
94 But err the other may by evil object,
95 Or by too much, or by too little vigour.
96 While in the first it well directed is,
97 And in the second moderates itself,
98 It cannot be the cause of sinful pleasure;
99 But when to ill it turns, and, with more care
100 Or lesser than it ought, runs after good,
101 'Gainst the Creator works his own creation.
102 Hence thou mayst comprehend that love must be
103 The seed within yourselves of every virtue,
104 And every act that merits punishment.
105 Now inasmuch as never from the welfare
106 Of its own subject can love turn its sight,
107 From their own hatred all things are secure;
108 And since we cannot think of any being
109 Standing alone, nor from the First divided,
110 Of hating Him is all desire cut off.
111 Hence if, discriminating, I judge well,
112 The evil that one loves is of one's neighbour,
113 And this is born in three modes in your clay.
114 It remains, if I reason correctly in making the proper distinctions, that the evil that is loved concerns one's neighbor; and this kind of mistaken love arises in you in three different ways. · Verses 112-114
There are, who, by abasement of their neighbour,
115 Hope to excel, and therefore only long
116 That from his greatness he may be cast down;
117 There are, who power, grace, honour, and renown
118 Fear they may lose because another rises,
119 Thence are so sad that the reverse they love;
120 There is the one who, fearing to lose power, favor, honor, or fame because someone else surpasses him, grows so grieved that he wishes ill upon the other. · Verses 118-120
And there are those whom injury seems to chafe,
121 So that it makes them greedy for revenge,
122 And such must needs shape out another's harm.
123 This threefold love is wept for down below;
124 Now of the other will I have thee hear,
125 That runneth after good with measure faulty.
126 This mistaken love, turned downward, is punished here below; now I want you to understand the other as well, which also aims at the good but with a corrupted order. · Verses 124-126
Each one confusedly a good conceives
127 Wherein the mind may rest, and longeth for it;
128 Therefore to overtake it each one strives.
129 Each one, even if confusedly, has a glimpse of a good in which the soul can find peace, and desires it; for this reason each one strives to attain it. · Verses 127-129
If languid love to look on this attract you,
130 Or in attaining unto it, this cornice,
131 After just penitence, torments you for it.
132 If love draws you with too little eagerness to behold it or to win it, this ledge torments you, after a just repentance, as punishment. · Verses 130-132
There's other good that does not make man happy;
133 'Tis not felicity, 'tis not the good
134 Essence, of every good the fruit and root.
135 There is, then, another good that does not make man happy; it is not happiness, it is not the perfect essence, root and fruit of every good. · Verses 133-135
The love that yields itself too much to this
136 Above us is lamented in three circles;
137 But how tripartite it may be described,
138 I say not, that thou seek it for thyself."
139 The list of places is under editorial review.
https://divinacommediaonline.it/en/purgatory/canto-17